On a mobile device? Try our mobile site, optimized for faster browsing.

Yelp New York

New York Steakhouses

Sammy's Roumanian Steakhouse

1. Sammy's Roumanian Steakhouse

4.5 star rating
38 reviews

We've been here twice, most recently for our engagement party.  Delicious lamb chops, latkes and probably some of the best chopped liver I've ever eaten.  Ever.  But we didn't choose Sammy's for the food.  It's the over-the-top fun atmosphere!  Have you ever danced the hora with a (non-Jewish) Puerto Rican woman who knew the steps perfectly?  I have here at Sammy's.  I believe the experience is…

Steakhouses in New York By Borough

Best New York Steakhouses By Feature

Related Steakhouses Searches

Best Steak

4.5 star rating 38 reviews

1. Sammy's Roumanian…

Neighborhood: Manhattan/Lower East Side

user photo

We've been here twice, most recently for our engagement party.  Delicious lamb chops, latkes and probably some of the best chopped liver I've ever eaten.  Ever.  But we didn't choose Sammy's...

4.5 star rating 67 reviews

2. BLT Prime

Neighborhood: Manhattan/Gramercy-Flatiron

user photo

The bacon appetizer... eh. Peter Luger's is better.  The steak... Ok. But again for this kind of money, you should get the best.  The fish special we ordered was extremely disappointing.  Oddly enough...

4.5 star rating 83 reviews

3. Landmarc

Neighborhood: Manhattan/TriBeCa

user photo

the best thing on the menu.  I would give Landmarc 2 stars if it weren't for the waitress.  She was nice, prompt, helpful and offered to replace my steak for free.  From all the great Yelp reviews, I...

4 star rating 59 reviews

4. Wolfgang's…

Neighborhood: Manhattan/Financial District

user photo

tender. It was also served with a nice buttery bernaise sauce. In addition to the wonderful steaks we also enjoyed an amazing creamed spinach side dish. It was, perhaps, the best creamed spinach I've...

4 star rating 282 reviews

5. Peter Luger Steak…

Neighborhood: Brooklyn/Williamsburg - South Side

user photo

Okay, I didn't try the bacon..and I should of...  =(  sounds like the best bacon in the whole world!!!! We order steak for 3, tomatoes and onion salad, broccoli and cream of spinach on the side...

More Best Steak in Steakhouses »

Juicy

4 star rating 282 reviews

1. Peter Luger Steak…

Neighborhood: Brooklyn/Williamsburg - South Side

user photo

juicy and cooked to perfection. Full of flavor and melts in your mouth. They serve you the whole bone with the filet.   I didn't really care for the fried German potatoes, since they were a little bit...

3.5 star rating 10 reviews

2. La Rural

Neighborhood: Manhattan/Manhattan Valley

user photo

if you are in the mood for a big juicy steak (and its a bit pricey to go to one of the classic New York steak houses) here you will be in the right place the decor, candles exposed brick lots of wood...

4 star rating 82 reviews

3. Strip House

Neighborhood: Manhattan/Greenwich Village

user photo

juicy and delicious as Wolfgang's or Peter Lugar's (No sizzling plate!) but is pretty damn close. My favorite cut here is the bone-in filet mignon.  Beware of the Strip Steak-- it was a bit saltier...

4 star rating 16 reviews

4. Morton's

Neighborhood: Manhattan/Midtown East

user photo

was exceptional and the food was delicious from the appetizer salad to the end.....we had no time for dessert, although we KNOW it would have been amazing. I had the double-cut filet mignon....juicy, tender...

4 star rating 9 reviews

5. Palm Too

Neighborhood: Manhattan/Midtown East

user photo

Grease attack!  Everything here can kill you...but at least it tastes good.  Not the best steak I've had, but it was indeed juicy.  But I don't like their salads.  Actually, I don't like salads...

More Juicy in Steakhouses »